Summary

While some horror TV shows are full of corny moments or awkward plot holes, Ryan Murphy’sAmerican Horror Storyis often at the top of its game. The genuinely creepy settings of haunted houses, small towns, an asylum, a strange circus, and a dangerous camp always draw viewers in, and every season has enough star power to keep viewers invested. Now that it’s been over a year since the season 12 finale aired, fans are ready for more.

Although it might bea while before fans get to seeAmerican Horror Storyseason 13,Murphy has shared his interest in continuing the eerie franchise in a few interviews. Fans wonder what the main plotline could be andif the next season will end the franchise. For now, there are no answers to these questions, but if the next season was a spinoff of one of the most beloved seasons, that would be fascinating.

Fiona, Madison, Nan, Zoe, and Queenie

American Horror Story Season 13 Should Be A Spinoff Of Coven

In a 2013 interview withThe Hollywood Reporter,Ryan Murphy talked about the possibility of making a spinoff ofAmerican Horror Story: Coven. He said:

“[FX CEO] John Landgrafand I have always spoken about how this is a show that is ripe to spin something off, to do something different. I already know what next season is. It’s not witches, but maybe something will happen. We’re talking about it. I have the next season ofHorror Storyalready plotted, and it’s quite different and fun.”

The witches in American Horror Story Coven

WhileAmerican Horror Story: Apocalypsefeatures some of the compelling and strong-willedCovencharacters, such as Queenie (Gabourey Sidibe), Cordelia Goode (Sarah Paulson), and Madison Montgomery (Emma Roberts), an official spinoff was never made. Season 13 could continue the story and dive even deeper into the lore of these witches. It would be great to see these three characters again, and sinceMurphy said he and Paulson are “cooking up something cool,“she’s definitely on board with a new season.

American Horror Storyseason 13 could bea prequel that shows how The Coven began. This would solve some potential plot holes since it would mean ignoring the events ofApocalypse, and it would also give fans the engaging backstory they’ve been hoping for. With 85% on Rotten Tomatoes, Coven is definitelyone of the most well-received seasons, and bringing back these smart and surprising witches would also please fans who are wondering about the long wait for the upcoming season.

American Horror Story Season 12 Poster

Ever sinceThe Blair Witch Projectcame out in 1999, witches have been an enduring horror trope, and there’s no end to the story possibilities. A new season ofAHScould introduce new members of the Coven, or an ancestor of Madison who started it all.

Fans Continue To Praise American Horror Story: Coven

Of course, not everyone has the same favoriteAmerican Horror Storyseason since horror fans have strong opinions about the best and most lackluster tropes. While some love tales about witches, others prefer ghost stories, want to see a new take on haunted houses, or appreciate the unique circus setting ofFreak Show. ButAmerican Horror Story: Covenis definitely up there, and many viewers have shared why they like it in a fewReddit threads. Redditor @Pure_Log5679 said it has, “Great acting Great story.“Another Redditor praised the talents ofAHSstaple actress Jessica Langeand Angela Bassett and wrote:

“It had a tight and focused story (…mostly) and it was cast well beyond expectations.”

In anotherReddit thread, one fan shared their equal love forCovenandseason 6, which was calledRoanoke.They appreciate “the story / characters / themes” ofCoven.